The lady pope maker of Rome

Engraving depicting the wedding of Marozia and Hugh of Italy, from Francesco Bertolini, Historia de Roma.

In the early tenth century, Rome was in a state of chaos. The great empire of Charlemagne had broken apart, leaving Italy unprotected1. Rome was weak and often attacked by invaders from the north and south3. The papacy (the office of the Pope) became a prize that rival noble families fought over5. Historians later called this violent and dark time the Saeculum Obscurum, or the "Dark Century"7.

Out of this chaos came a powerful woman named Marozia. Born around 890, she grew up to control kings, remove popes from power, and rule Rome9. For a long time, male historians called her terrible names and labeled this period the Pornocracy, meaning "rule of whores"7.

However, this article looks at her life differently. By looking at her marriages, how she chose popes, and her powerful titles of Senatrix and Patricia, we see a highly capable leader9. In a world completely ruled by men, she used marriage and family-building to create her own empire.

Background and family power

To understand Marozia's success, we must look at her powerful family. She was the daughter of Theophylact I, the Count of Tusculum, and Theodora, a very smart and political woman9. Theophylact was a powerful leader who became the military and civil ruler of Rome14.

He shared his power with his wife, Theodora. She took the titles of Senatrix and serenissima vestaratrix and helped choose the popes14. A writer named Liutprand of Cremona, who hated her family, called Theodora a "shameless whore" who ruled like a man9. This insult shows that Liutprand was mostly upset that a woman was holding so much power17.

Marozia learned from her mother. She saw that even though women were not allowed to hold official roles, they could still control the men in charge19. Her family knew that whoever controlled the Pope controlled the Church's wealth and power.

Building a dynasty

When she was just fifteen, Marozia entered Roman politics9. Around 904, her family helped Pope Sergius III take power. Liutprand of Cremona wrote that teenage Marozia had an affair with Pope Sergius III, and they had a son who later became Pope John XI9.

Because of this story, older historians called Marozia a seductress who ruined the Church5. But we must be careful with this claim. Liutprand wrote this fifty years later and hated the Roman nobles21. He wanted to make them look bad25. Another writer from that time, Flodoard, wrote that Pope John XI was actually the son of Marozia and her first husband, Alberic I9. If Flodoard is right, the story about the Pope was just a rumor meant to hurt Marozia's reputation25.

Even if the affair did happen, it showed Marozia's smart planning. Women could not be generals or popes, so family and marriage were their best tools27. By having a child with the Pope, she made sure her family would stay in power.

First marriage and the Battle of Garigliano

Around 909, Marozia's family arranged a smart marriage for her9. She married Alberic I, the strong Duke of Spoleto. This marriage brought together her family's political power and his military strength.

They needed this strength because Arab raiders, called Saracens, were attacking the lands around Rome4. Pope John X organized a large Christian army to fight them4. In June 915, this army fought the Battle of Garigliano. Alberic I was a main commander in this big battle4. The Christian forces trapped the Saracens by a river and defeated them completely21.

This victory stopped the attacks and made Alberic I very famous21. During this calm period, Marozia had children, including Alberic II, born around 911 or 9129.

Overthrowing Pope John X

In 924, Marozia's husband Alberic I was murdered9. Soon after, both of her parents died too. Being a widow without a male protector was very dangerous in those times. Pope John X tried to use this chance to take power away from Marozia's family9.

But Marozia refused to give up. To protect herself and get a new army, she married Guy, the powerful ruler of Tuscany, in 92510. With Guy's army, Marozia fought back. In May 928, she and Guy attacked the Lateran Palace, where the Pope lived9. They arrested Pope John X and put him in the dungeon of Castel Sant'Angelo, Marozia's strong fortress9.

A few months later, Pope John X died in prison. Most historians believe Marozia and Guy had him smothered with a pillow9. By removing a sitting pope, Marozia showed that her power was greater than the Church's.

Table 1: Marozia's marriages

Spouse	Date of Marriage	Reason for Marriage	Result
Alberic I, Duke of Spoleto	c. 909	To get a strong army to protect her family.	They had a son (Alberic II) and won a major battle9.
Guy, Margrave of Tuscany	c. 925	To get an army to fight Pope John X.	They captured the Pope, and Marozia took control of Rome.
Hugh of Arles, King of Italy	932	To become Queen of Italy.	Her son started a rebellion, and Marozia was locked in prison1.

Ruling Rome and making Popes

After getting rid of John X, Marozia was the clear ruler of Rome. From 928 to 932, she was at her most powerful. Pope John X had previously given her the special titles of Senatrix (senatoress) and Patricia of Rome9. These titles meant she was the official, legal leader of the city.

She ruled like a queen, making her own coins and signing important documents13. The military and city workers answered to her. She also chose the next popes to make sure the Church did what she wanted. Pope Leo VI and Pope Stephen VII were completely under her control. In 931, she made her own 21-year-old son, John, the new Pope (Pope John XI). This showed how much she controlled the Church. The highest religious leader in Europe was now her own son.

Table 2: The Popes Marozia controlled (928-935)

Pope	Years Ruled	Relationship to Marozia
Pope Leo VI	928	Chosen by Marozia and followed her orders.
Pope Stephen VII	928–931	Chosen by Marozia to keep the Church under her control.
Pope John XI	931–935	Her own son, showing she had total control over the Church9.

A Third marriage and a big mistake

Marozia's second husband, Guy, died in 929. Now she wanted even more power. She wanted to be Queen of Italy. To do this, she planned to marry Hugh of Arles, the King of Italy2. Hugh wanted to control Rome, so the marriage helped them both1.

However, there was a big problem: Hugh was the half-brother of Marozia's dead husband, Guy1. Church law said they could not marry. Marozia ignored the rules and had her son, Pope John XI, approve the marriage anyway1.

In the summer of 932, Hugh arrived in Rome, and they had a huge wedding at Castel Sant'Angelo3. Marozia had reached the top: she was the ruler of Rome, the mother of the Pope, and the Queen of Italy. But this is exactly when everything fell apart.

Her son's rebellion and her fall

Marozia made a mistake by ignoring her son, Alberic II. He was angry about her new marriage because he felt Rome belonged to him22. During the wedding, King Hugh slapped Alberic II in the face1.

This insult started a disaster. Alberic ran out and gave a passionate speech to the people of Rome. He told them that King Hugh was a foreign tyrant who would take away their freedom1. The angry people of Rome started a rebellion.

In December 932, a large mob led by Alberic II attacked Castel Sant'Angelo22. King Hugh got scared, escaped by climbing down a rope at night, and ran away, leaving Marozia behind1. Her own son captured her22.

Alberic II took control of Rome and made his brother, Pope John XI, focus only on church duties, taking away his political power22. Marozia was locked in the same dark prison where she had put Pope John X22. She lived there alone for five years until she died around 937.

Her family's legacy

Even though Marozia died in prison, her family stayed in power. Her son Alberic II ruled Rome until 95416. Before he died, he made sure his son Octavian (Marozia's grandson) would become the next pope. Octavian became Pope John XII in 9555.

Marozia's family produced many popes over the next hundred years5. This family later became the famous Colonna family, meaning Marozia's descendants shaped European history for a very long time5.

Table 3: Popes from Marozia's Family

Pope	Years Ruled	Relationship to Marozia	History
Pope John XI	931–935	Son	Put in power by Marozia.
Pope John XII	955–964	Grandson	United political and church power in Rome.
Pope John XIII	965–972	Nephew	Kept the family in power5.
Pope Benedict VIII	1012–1024	Great-grandson	Defeated rivals and fought invaders.
Pope John XIX	1024–1032	Great-grandson	Kept the family rule going strong9.
Pope Benedict IX	1032–1048	Great-great-grandson	The last pope from her direct family line.

Rethinking history

For a long time, male historians judged Marozia unfairly. The word "Pornocracy" (rule of whores) was not used when she was alive. It was created much later by writers who wanted to make the Church look bad7. They used the angry writings of Liutprand of Cremona to claim that women ruined the papacy14.

Today, modern historians see things differently19. When we look past the insults, we see that Marozia was a very smart and capable leader. She did not rule just because she was beautiful. She ruled because she understood politics, armies, and how to build strong alliances.

She took the title of Senatrix to show she was a true Roman leader. Male writers were scared of her because she was successful. In a world where women were supposed to be quiet, she gave orders and defeated powerful men9.

Conclusions

Marozia's story is not an embarrassing mistake in history. It is a story of a smart woman surviving and winning in a dangerous world. She built a powerful family that saved Rome from total chaos. She proved that women could handle power just as well as men. Even though she died in prison, her influence lived on in the popes and leaders who came after her. Marozia refused to be a pawn in the games of men; instead, she became the player who controlled the board.

Works cited

1. the popes in the days of feudal anarchy - Cristo Raul.org, https://www.cristoraul.org/ENGLISH/readinghall/THIRDMILLENNIUMLIBRARY/History-of-the-popes/MANN/THE-POPES-IN-THE-DAYS-OF-FEUDAL-ANARCHY_891-1048.htm

2. Italy and the Papal Pornocracy 800 – 1100, https://paulbuddehistory.com/europe/italy-and-the-papal-pornocracy-800-1100/

3. Death and Life in the Tenth Century 0472061720, 9780472061723, https://dokumen.pub/death-and-life-in-the-tenth-century-0472061720-9780472061723.html

4. Battle of Garigliano - Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Garigliano

5. The Papacy: Nicholas I and the Pornocracy (855-964), https://greatbooksguy.com/2022/07/07/the-papacy-nicholas-i-and-the-pornocracy-855-964/

6. “Apostles of Apostasy”: Caesar Baronius and the Saeculum, https://theologiaetvita.blogspot.com/2025/05/apostles-of-apostasy-caesar-baronius.html

7. Aspects of Medieval Society - Himachal Pradesh University, https://www.hpuniv.ac.in/hpuniv/upload/uploadfiles/files/HIST%20103%20MA_%20Aspects%20of%20Medieval%20Society_compressed.pdf

8. Renaissance & Middle Ages - Historical Easter Eggs - Today in History, https://todayinhistory.blog/category/renaissance-middle-ages/

9. Marozia - Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marozia

10. Marozia Facts for Kids, https://kids.kiddle.co/Marozia

11. Marozia e la pornocrazia pontificia - Viaggiatori Ignoranti, https://www.viaggiatoriignoranti.it/2018/11/marozia-e-la-pornocrazia-pontificia.html

12. When Harlots Ruled the Church - Catholic World Report, https://www.catholicworldreport.com/2023/08/27/when-harlots-ruled-the-church/

13. The Mysteries of History: Unravelling the Truth from the Myths of Our, https://dokumen.pub/the-mysteries-of-history-unravelling-the-truth-from-the-myths-of-our-past-9781782439028-9781782439691-1782439021.html

14. Theophylact I, Count of Tusculum - Military Wiki | Fandom, https://military-history.fandom.com/wiki/Theophylact_I,_Count_of_Tusculum

15. Marozia - Enciclopedia - Treccani, https://www.treccani.it/enciclopedia/marozia_(Dizionario-di-Storia)/

16. Theophylact I, Count of Tusculum - Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theophylact_I,_Count_of_Tusculum

17. Theodora (senatrix) | Catholicism Wiki, https://catholicism.wiki/article/theodora-senatrix-wp1335079

18. The Pig in Pornocrates - MDPI, https://www.mdpi.com/2076-0752/15/6/131

19. 10 Medieval Studies' Articles Published Last Month - Medievalists.net, https://www.medievalists.net/2025/08/medieval-studies-articles-july-2025/

20. (PDF) Women and Gender in the Forum Romanum - Academia.edu, https://www.academia.edu/9874003/Women_and_Gender_in_the_Forum_Romanum

21. Sergius Rome (0860-0911) | WikiTree FREE Family Tree, https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Rome-210

22. The dark age (saeculum obscura) : r/darksouls3 - Reddit, https://www.reddit.com/r/darksouls3/comments/fypjl0/the_dark_age_saeculum_obscura/

23. List of sexually active popes - Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sexually_active_popes

24. Pope John X - Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pope_John_X

25. The Complete Works of Liudprand of Cremona 0813215064, https://dokumen.pub/the-complete-works-of-liudprand-of-cremona-0813215064-9780813215068.html

26. THE INTERESTS OF HISTORIANS IN THE TENTH CENTURY, https://www.brepolsonline.net/doi/pdf/10.1484/M.SEM-EB.3.4712?download=true

27. Anne of France & lessons for daughters in history of anti-meninism, https://www.purplemotes.net/2016/03/27/anne-of-france-lessons-daughters/

28. Marozia - Enciclopedia - Treccani, https://www.treccani.it/enciclopedia/marozia_(Dizionario-Biografico)/

29. Marozia - Wikipedia, https://cs.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marozia

30. Mihi es aemula: Elite female status competition in Mid-Republican, https://www.academia.edu/35001562/Mihi_es_aemula_Elite_female_status_competition_in_Mid_Republican_Rome_and_the_example_of_Tertia_Aemilia

31. Kingdoms of Italy - Bishops of Rome / Popes - The History Files, https://www.historyfiles.co.uk/KingListsEurope/ItalyPopes.htm

32. 1899 FEDELE Garigliano 915 AD: Christian League Destroys The, https://it.scribd.com/document/102009922/1899-FEDELE-Garigliano-915-AD-Christian-League-destroys-the-Saracen-Stronghold-near-Rome

33. Counts of Tusculum - Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Counts_of_Tusculum

34. Ищу консультантов для работы над романом - Книжная полка, https://istorya.ru/forum/index.php?showtopic=4659

35. A Dictionary of popes [2 ed.] 9780192820853, 0192820850, https://dokumen.pub/a-dictionary-of-popes-2nbsped-9780192820853-0192820850-9780199295814-0199295816.html

36. The deaths of the popes: comprehensive accounts, including, https://dokumen.pub/the-deaths-of-the-popes-comprehensive-accounts-including-funerals-burial-places-and-epitaphs-9780786461165-2004014712.html

37. juli | 2014 | Worldwide guide to women in leadership | Side 2, https://guidetowomenleaderscom.wordpress.com/2014/07/page/2/

38. Marozia - Grokipedia, https://grokipedia.com/page/Marozia

39. The Vatican's Women: Female Influence at the Holy See - AbeBooks, https://www.abebooks.com/9780312274900/Vaticans-Women-Female-Influence-Holy-0312274904/plp

40. A History Of The Popes: From Peter To The Present [PDF] - Vdoc.pub, https://vdoc.pub/documents/a-history-of-the-popes-from-peter-to-the-present-41gs7uod7000

41. Open Letter on Fabricated Illness | PDF | Irenaeus | Paul The Apostle, https://www.scribd.com/document/102860503/Notes-on-Church-History

42. Rome on the Borders: Visual Cultures During the Carolingian, https://dokumen.pub/rome-on-the-borders-visual-cultures-during-the-carolingian-transition-8021097108-9788021097100.html

43. Ravenna: Its Role In Earlier Medieval Change And Exchange [PDF], https://vdoc.pub/documents/ravenna-its-role-in-earlier-medieval-change-and-exchange-79u69bd4q1e0